The Team

One advocate, backed by the whole house

When you work with Legacy, you work with one agent who knows your file cold, and behind them stands a brokerage led by two owners who still work their own files: shared market intelligence, in-house coordination, and a standard every one of us works by. Our REALTORS® each have their own market roots across West Michigan, and they all answer to the same promise. Straight answers and real strategy.

Behind the Agents

The Team That Runs the House

It starts with the two people who founded Legacy and still run it, Terry Puffer and Dave Manley. An agent is the person you talk to. Behind them sits the rest of Legacy, the people who coordinate the transactions, keep the books, manage the properties, and handle inspections, plus Lakeside Construction Services, our in-house construction company. Same standard, one roof.

Terry Puffer
Terry Puffer
Co-Founder and Owner · Team Lead, REALTOR®
Dave Manley
Dave Manley
Co-Founder and Owner · Broker, REALTOR®
Chloe Cavanaugh
Chloe Cavanaugh
Director of Operations
Krista McLaughlin
Krista McLaughlin
Transaction Coordinator
Kelly Zwack
Kelly Zwack
Transaction Coordinator · REALTOR®
Nicole Mancha
Nicole Mancha
Business and Marketing Development
Sam Chavaliere
Sam Chavaliere
Accounting
Jake Samlow
Jake Samlow
Lead Inspector · Licensed Builder
Taylor Witt
Taylor Witt
Lakeside Construction Services

How Matching Works

Tell Us Your Situation. We Will Listen First.

Step One

One Conversation

Call, message, or stop by. Tell us what you are trying to do, where, and on what timeline. No forms longer than they need to be, no scripts.

Step Two

An Honest Match

We connect you with the Legacy agent whose market roots and experience actually fit your situation, not whoever is next in a rotation.

Step Three

Your Advocate

From that point forward you have one person in your corner, backed by the whole house, working your outcome and nothing else.

For Real Estate Professionals

Think You Belong on This Roster?

Legacy was built to help agents reach the professional level they always imagined, with real structure behind them. If you are building a real estate career and this page reads like the kind of house you want behind you, we should talk.

Call Legacy · (231) 900-1099